Bulgaria's Supreme Administrative Court has upheld a €319,607.02 (625,097 leva) fine on the National Electricity Company (NEK) for manipulating the wholesale energy market. The fine is now final. The Energy and Water Regulatory Commission (KEVR) said the court ruled on 4 November, overturning a 2024 decision by the Sofia City Administrative Court and rejecting the company's appeal.

KEVR imposed the fine on 25 November 2022. It found that NEK had broken Article 5 of Regulation (EU) No 1227/2011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2011, which bans manipulation of the wholesale energy market. The inquiry began after reports from the Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators and from the Bulgarian Independent Energy Exchange. It covered trades made between 1 February and 30 June 2019. At the same closed meeting, KEVR found violations by six market participants in all.

KEVR says NEK made three groups of trades with five other energy companies, and that together they broke the ban: "wash" trades of the ABA type, trades in block products, and cross-trades between the exchange's two segments, Day-Ahead and Intraday.

ABA trades are series of purchases and sales in which a trader's interest and market risk barely change. NEK made 208 of them, 20 to 24 seconds apart, at a price of €41.70. The cross-trades moved the same amounts of electricity. It was bought on the Day-Ahead market and then sold to NEK on the Intraday market at a higher price. The block products were 61 purchases with a total volume of 46,460 megawatt-hours, worth €946,482 (1,851,158 leva).

The regulator says the exact match in volumes shows that the trades were agreed in advance and that the companies shared information.

KEVR also cited the court's reasoning. The regulator's decision describes the trades, the period, the market segments and the companies' conduct in enough detail to prove indirectly that they coordinated. The court rejected the arguments that there is no direct evidence of a deal and that trading on the exchange is anonymous. To prove manipulation, it is not necessary to show that the market was actually distorted or that the trader had a specific intent. It is enough that the conduct could send false signals about demand, supply or price. It is also enough that it could push the price to an artificial level. NEK did not show any legitimate reason for its actions.

KEVR says the ruling gives a clear guide on how to prove manipulation in exchange trading, and it confirms court practice on applying the regulation in Bulgaria. It also backs the work of KEVR's Monitoring and Control of Regulation (EU) No 1227/2011 directorate. The commission adds that constant oversight helps keep competition fair and wholesale energy prices fair, especially at a time of geopolitical uncertainty.