In 86% of about 1,000 cases where platforms left up reported, potentially fraudulent content, the content broke the platforms' own rules. That is the finding of a new report covering October 2025 to September 2026 from Appeals Centre Europe (ACE) in Dublin. The body is certified under the EU's Digital Services Act and settles such disputes out of court.

In almost 5,000 decisions where ACE could see the content itself, it disagreed with the platform in 74% of cases. In its previous report the figure was 59%. The share covers all types of disputes, not just scams.

Disputes: 90-day target, no fee

ACE is independent of the platforms and works under Article 21 of the act. It covers Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Pinterest, Threads, YouTube and Google Maps. A dispute can be about content the platform removed or left up, an account suspension, or the closure of a page, group or channel.

Users must be in an EU country. They file a dispute through the centre's portal in English, French, German, Spanish, Italian, Polish or Dutch. A six-month deadline applies to removed content or a suspended account. There is no deadline for harmful content that is still online. There is no fee. ACE aims to decide within 90 days, and complex cases can take up to 180. In Bulgaria, the certifying body under the act is the Communications Regulation Commission. Using such a body does not take away the right to go to court.

ACE's decision is not binding. Platforms must review it and act in good faith, but they decide for themselves whether to restore or remove the content. The centre has limited information on whether its decisions are carried out. It says it works with Ireland's regulator, Coimisiún na Meán, and the European Commission to get the decisions applied.

More than 19,000 eligible disputes

ACE overturned YouTube's decisions in 93% of cases, TikTok's in 77%, Instagram's in 75% and Facebook's in 67%. Pinterest had only 17 eligible disputes, too few to draw a conclusion. The data comes only from disputes that users filed themselves, so it does not show how often platforms make mistakes overall.

In total, ACE has received more than 65,000 disputes from across the EU. Of these, 43,000 came in the reporting period, or about one every 12 minutes. More than 19,000 are eligible for review, most of them from France, Belgium and Spain. Disputes have tripled compared with a year earlier. From April to September 2026, scams and fake offers were the area with the most eligible disputes in the EU.

AI makes scams harder to spot. ACE gives three examples. One is an AI-generated TikTok video of a woman who is supposedly looking for a serious relationship and wants money sent to her. Another is a fake Facebook video of a Moldovan economic expert promising a 2,000% profit. The third is a YouTube clip about cryptocurrencies whose link probably gave scammers access to viewers' accounts.

Part of the problem is that platforms do not send the content for review. In about 10,000 decisions, mostly on suspended accounts, the material was not sent, and ACE ruled for the user on procedural grounds. Google provided only two of more than 850 items of content requested.

The bank, the police and reporting

A dispute with ACE does not get money back. If a person has already sent money or given details to a scammer, the National Police advise ending the conversation and checking the information by calling the bank on the official number on its website, not the one the caller gave. People can report it on 112 or at the nearest police station. The police advice covers phone scams, not scams on social networks.

The first step is to report the content to the platform. Only if it leaves the content up can the user file a dispute with ACE.