The Fiscal Council says pension reform should build up the second pillar, the personal accounts in the universal pension funds. It should not move contributions from those accounts to the state social security system (DOO), the council said in its opinion on the draft 2027 DOO budget.

The council wants more of future pensions to come from the money saved in personal accounts. It says moving contributions to the DOO would cut the shortfall in the state pension fund for a time, but would add to the first pillar's future obligations. The council backs without reservation a plan to bring the social security burden on civil servants and magistrates in line with that on other workers. It also wants people employed in the "Defence and Security" sector included in the changes. One set of rules for everyone will prevent a two-tier system and tension between workers in different sectors, the council says.

Under the draft, DOO income from social security contributions will grow by 11.9% next year, while spending will rise by 8.3%. The deficit does not shrink in cash terms. It only grows more slowly, by 3.7%, to €6.7bn. As a share of gross domestic product (GDP), the value of everything produced in the country in a year, it falls from 5% to 4.75%, but only because nominal GDP growth is higher. The DOO budget balances only because a transfer from the state budget covers the shortfall. The council says the improvement comes mainly from contribution ceilings raised by administrative order, not from changes to the system itself.

Pensions are still too uniform, the opinion says, and the link between what people paid in and what they get is weak. Some 45.5% of pensioners receive a minimum or social pension. The replacement rate, which shows what share of earlier income a pension covers, falls to 51.6%.

Parliament's budget committee yesterday backed the 2027 DOO draft budget at first reading, along with the draft law on the 2027 budget of the National Health Insurance Fund (NZOK).

Almost three quarters of the health fund's payments go to hospitals and medicines, which also account for more than 70% of the rise in spending. Spending is growing more slowly than in past years, but at almost the same pace as nominal GDP. The council says this means their share is only holding steady, not shrinking. The stated priority of outpatient care and prevention does not show clearly enough in how the money is split. In line with its position on the 2027 budget, the council insists that health spending be held steady in real terms until 2029 through efficiency steps, not by limiting access to health services.

The first priority in health care is a spending review using the approach the European Commission recommends, with quantitative targets and result indicators, which do not exist now. The council also proposes to restructure hospital care, moving some services to outpatient care, and to bring in a new way of paying hospitals. Medical providers should be paid for quality and results, households should pay less out of pocket, and medicines should be used more efficiently rather than restricted. The NZOK reserve of €169m, or 3%, should be spent under clear rules.